*Hedwig’s Theme plays while the words in this post float into focus*
If only, right? Anyway, if you caught my last post like this you know that I’m rereading the HP series as the illustrated versions are released. (Also, I’m taking my time. I know they’ve already released #3 and I’m just finishing the second one. I know, guys 😜) So anyway, I’ve collected my thoughts on The Chamber of Secrets because I know you’ve been dying to read them.
*No true spoilers, but there’s alluding. Just FYI
The movie makes the escape from the Dursley’s house much more dramatic than it actually is…
Fred and George (F&G) damn near figure out the whole mystery in Chpt 3.
You learn SO much more about the Weasleys in the books.
Lucius Malfoy actually behaves like a father in the books (but also like an ass).
I found myself reading with vigilance during the exchange with the Malfoys in the bookstore.
There’s a lot more fist fighting in the books, lol. I like it.
Prof. McGonagall will always be my favorite professor.
The scene from the movie with Neville fainting during the Mandrake re-potting didn’t happen in the book, which makes more sense to me. He had a knack for herbology. The movie makes him look like a doofus in everything but that wasn’t true.
Lockhart in incredibly infuriating. Like Umbridge, we all know someone who behaves that way and it makes them hateable in a relative way.
I feel like Jo was making a very pointed statement about the Slytherin house when she pointed out that there were no females on their quidditch team (and 3 on Gryffindor’s).
The way F&G fight for what’s right, regardless of who or what they’re defending, makes me love them so so so much.
I’d have liked to see the Deathday Party portrayed in the movie. Ha.
The dueling scene is way more comical than the film gives it credit for…
I wish they’d have included the Dursley’s Christmas gift to Harry in the movie.
The comparison of Hermione to McGonagall is 👌 perfect.
Malfoy’s a right git. He speaks so openly about killing Mudbloods. He makes the movie version likeable. Grrr…
In the book Tom has motive to report the heir… It doesn’t show that in the movie.
I forgot the spider hunt is actually Ron’s first time in the Forbidden Forest.
The sadness in the Gryffindor common room after Ginny is taken is so heartbreaking. (highlight for name)
I think Harry & Ron should’ve gotten some credit for at least trying to put the dangerous tasks in the adults’ hands…
Things explained in this book: Hagrid’s umbrella, the broken vanishing cabinet
I loved the handful of things alluded to- especially in regards to horcruxes.
I watch the films all the time when they’re on TV but I haven’t read the books in year. I know a lot of this was comparisons to the movies. It’s just strange (and sometimes sad) to see what they left out.
If you’re wondering if I’ll ever stop fangirling for the Weasley twins or praising McGonagall’s name the answer is NOPE. Also, I’ve said it a million times but these illustrated books give me all the heart eyes. I can’t wait to crack open the third!
So what’re your thoughts on The Chamber of Secrets? How about the film?